Yorkie: Peninsulater!

If you take the ferry over to Ward’s island and follow the path along the south side of the quaint island community, you’ll soon come through some thick trees and come up against the east side of Ward’s itself. There’s not much there; a thin, crumbling concrete strip jutting out from the shore, and the usually vacant-looking Toronto port, 600-odd feet on the other side of the channel.  It does offer a pretty fantastic view of downtown, and in the summer you’ll see sailboats and kayaks going through the canal, taking scenic routes around the big park. But it wasn’t always that way. It never is. Dun dun dun.

If you’ve read this post you’ll know the island had its first building, the Gibraltar Point Lighthouse, built in 1808. There weren’t many permanent residents for a few decades, but by the mid 1800s it was a pretty happening place. Part of the reason for that was that at this point, it wasn’t the Toronto islands at all. It was a peninsula, connected on the East side by a strip of land that splayed out Westward into a marshy bay.

map 1792
One of the first British plans for the town of York in 1792 – look at how connected that land is!


In 1833 the first hotel, called the Retreat on the Peninsula, was built on the island – even then people wanted a peaceful getaway from the urban sprawl.   The hotel changed hands a number of times between 1833 and 1858. Over that period of time, that thin slice of connecting land got thinner and thinner as amusements and some houses were built. There were ferries that shipped people and stuffs over from the mainland, but there was still foot traffic that came across the East side.

August 1857 marked the beginning of the end for our dear peninsula. There were a couple of particularly nasty storms, one of which caused the hotel proprietor to evacuate (himself, his family, his guests, and his furniture. Must’ve been really nice beaver pelt couches or something). The seaward wall caved in and the roof almost got torn off before the storm eventually subsided. It was basically just a large sandbar though. I’m pretty sure it went down a little something like this.  Needless to say, I don’t think the hotel did much business after that.

Hotel 1850
The hotel in 1850. Also…is that a beaver tied to a doghouse? And a deer fenced in?! And TWO GIANT GUILLOTINES?!?!? What IS this place?!


By January of the next year, a report by the Harbour Commissioner’s Office confirmed that the thinnest portion of the peninsula had been fully washed over, and confirmed that it was no longer a peninsula, but an island. They dredged the gap out a bit and put up some walls to ensure it was safely traversable by ship, and the Eastern Gap was born.  Over 150 years later, we’ve never looked back. Here’s an image of the map in 1910:

Map 1910
1910. I’m not REALLY curious about what looks like a subdivision over there in Simcoe Park. I wanna live in Simcoe Park!! #NoJetsTO


And here’s the map today.

The full report of the Harbour Commisioner’s is actually really interesting – he talks about how the change will be good for the sanitation of the city, and reminisces about the good old days of grazing cattle and plenty of trees on the peninsula.

If you’re interested, you can read it below – these excerpts were found in the January 18th edition The Globe, from a report given on January 14th by Hugh Richardson, Harbor Master at the Harbour Commissioner’s Office:


“In reporting upon the state of the Harbour, I cannot avoid mentioning, as connected with it, the great change that has taken place in the aspect of the late Peninsula, now a confirmed Island. … the late gales in December last, as reported to me by the Island watchmen, have opened … further west, sweeping away fifty trees, nearly the last of the last remaining clump. … The sea now ranges freely over most of the remaining beach in all easterly and southerly gales, and the marsh is detaching in large masses and floating about the bay.

In a sanitary point of view along, this may be of great advantage; for agitation being inimical to marsh growth, the action of the wave will destroy all within its range.  Already a very large space within the bay is open water.

Those who remember the Peninsula thirty years ago, with its broad neck, its groves of trees, its cattle feed, and lake road under a high bank, will now on visiting it, find all replaced by a permanent and wide opening to the lake, and a low, narrow strip of beach extending west, almost without a tree, over nearly the whole of which the sea ranges during north-east gales.

The Peninsula destroyed, marks the first great phase of change in the barrier that forms the southern boundary of the port of Toronto.  Its connexion [sic] with the mainland cut off, bereft of all material supply, the future results of nature’s operations on the island must be destructive.

The people on the Island report the whole line of beach West as wearing away, and the light-keeper at Gibraltar point, announces that point as greatly reduced.  At the same time a resident at Blockhouse Bay reports the great increase of the tongue of the Island that forms the Bay, tawards [sic] the interior of the Harbour; indicating by that sign, a draught[sic] of current from West to East; the water in strong S.W. gales finding egress by the mouths of the Don through the marsh and out at the opening in Ashbridge’s Bay; instead of being forced to return by under current to the mouth of the Bay of Toronto and by the navigable channel.

In my statements of facts in regard to the state of the harbour I assume myself to be correct.  As to opinions that I may have ventured, they are my own, and can only have weight as they bear upon truth or probability.  To the many the harbour is what it appears upon its surface, time and disposition are given to few to observe and to reflect upon its changes.  It is for the professionally scientific to suggest with the weight of their knowledge and experience, measures for the preservation of the Harbour.”

Who says history is boring?!?!?!

Add your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s